The American Flamingo, Part 1
Lawn as American Vernacular | Diagnosing the nation, one lawn ornament at a time
Good morning, earthlings.
Welcome to a new series looking at America through the lens of our lawn ornaments.
In June 2024, a wild American flamingo was spotted off the coast of Cape Cod. The bizarre sighting made headlines across the country, delighting beachgoers and throwing the local birding community into absolute pandemonium. Video footage captured the bird feeding on the sand flats near Chapin Beach, nearly 1200 miles from its breeding grounds in the Bahamas. According to the Audubon Society, it was the northernmost observation of a flamingo ever recorded along the Atlantic.1 Hardcore birders drove as far as six hours to see it, but by the time they arrived, it had vanished. Speculation of the bird’s origins rippled across the internet: it had escaped from the zoo, it was blown in by a hurricane, it was simply a mirage, or a hoax pushed by the media. What every account failed to recognize is that the most common species of flamingo in North America is, in fact, endemic to Massachusetts.
* * *
In 1957, a factory worker at Union Products in Leominster, MA, dumped a hundred kilograms of colored polyethylene pellets into a 350-degree industrial oven. The molten pink goo was extruded through a large hole to form a wide hollow tube, which was pressed from both sides by a set of S-shaped aluminum molds. The first pink plastic flamingo was born. His name was Diego.
Designed by 21-year-old art school graduate Don Featherstone, the pink plastic flamingo has become one of the most iconic and ubiquitous figures in American pop culture: an infectious symbol of post-war leisure and optimism, and a deliciously unsubtle barometer of suburban taste and class. Epitomized by John Waters’ 1972 cult classic Pink Flamingos, the popular lawn ornament has become a visual shorthand for all things tacky and irreverent. A permanent resident of trailer parks and tiki bars across the nation, the birds are remarkably cosmopolitan, migrating freely between bachelorette parties, campus ragers, Park Ave brownstones, and Fire Island orgies—and making cameos in films like Barbie and Edward Scissorhands, as well as (more recently) in my own backyard.
During a prolonged period of Vitamin D deficiency last December, I spent four and a half hours hunting down a pair of original mint-condition Featherstone flamingos on eBay. The birds came nestled in a windowed cardboard box decorated with palm trees and stamped with the words “Made in USA.” I swear to God they smelled like coconuts. Outside, a dirty snowplow lumbered down the street, pushing a line of gray sludge against the curb and spraying sodium chloride from its salt-crusted backside. It was the first real New York blizzard in a winter of many.
As I wiggled the metal spokes into the holes on one’s underside, the echoes of an ancient spell rose from deep within me. This ancestral chanting—Kokomo, kokomo—carried me hypnotically to the backyard where, with the ritual precision of a spear fisherman, I plunged the metal spokes deep into the snow. Instantly, a wave of pink warmth washed over me, melting all critical defenses. For the first time in weeks, I laughed out loud. For the next half hour, I stood outside in my flip-flops and pajama shorts, smiling giddily, tracing the form-molded ripples of its feathers, following the elegant curve of its neck, admiring its beady black eyes and airbrushed lips. In the darkest depths of my quiet desperation, this form-molded phoenix had come to save me. I saw God that day, and let me tell you: She was pink.
Look, guys: no one is immune to kitsch. No one. As an aesthetic category, it’s simply too powerful—pure sentimentality shot straight to the veins. The theorist Walter Benjamin described kitsch as “instantaneous emotional gratification without intellectual effort2”—a kind of aesthetic junk food that trips the reward centers of our brain while providing little nourishment for the soul. Like Moon Pies and Fritos, kitsch embodies the logic of mass production, serving up pre-packaged emotional pleasures with remarkable convenience and efficiency. In the case of my beloved flamingo: an immediate feeling of paradise, rendered portable and pink.
Kitsch is often distinguished from true art in that it does not challenge the viewer; it simply soothes and sedates. But isn’t that part of the appeal? Kitsch is fun because it’s free of emotional ambiguity. Kitschy objects tell us exactly what to feel, and that what we should feel is good. We are exempted from the demands of the gallery or the cinema—kitsch requires no critical distance, no intellectual exchange. It is the logic of pure leisure, the brain as a white sand beach. Piña coladas, palm trees, a never-ending out-of-office. This is the world the flamingo beckons. And by god, we deserve it.
Like many artifacts in the pantheon of poor taste—McMansions, Hallmark movies, the entire city of Las Vegas—the plastic flamingo reveals itself to be a rich cultural text, embodying subconscious desires and collective anxieties around issues of class, leisure, nature, and domesticity. Its preferred habitat—the American lawn—is perhaps the ultimate stage for these cultural tensions: a miniaturized distillation of our nation’s ideals around land ownership, conformity, and collective life. To understand the role the flamingo plays in the American psyche, we must consider it as both disruptor and ambassador to a larger ecosystem: the lawn as a battleground of politics and taste, still playing out in physical space.
The Great Green River
“When smiling lawns and tasteful cottages begin to embellish the country, we know that order and culture are established… the interest manifested in the Rural Architecture of a country like this, has much to do with the progress of its civilization.”
- Andrew Jackson Downing, The Architecture of Country Houses
In his Notes on the State of Virginia, Thomas Jefferson laid out a grand vision for America: a republic of yeoman farmers, each with their own plot of land, in an infinite grid stretching westward. America was to be a sprawling nation of self-sufficient agrarians, materially independent from the tyrannies of aristocracy, kept morally virtuous through their sustained connection with the land. Fast forward two hundred and fifty years, and the descendants of the pioneers are in the front yard fighting dandelions.
The suburban lawn is the ersatz version of Jefferson’s yeoman farm—a warped vision of land ownership stripped of the ideals of moral and bodily sustenance; in its place, a vast green desert, fueled by chemical dependencies and the aesthetics of the European elite. The landscape architects are to blame here, of course. Frederick Law Olmsted and Andrew Jackson Downing—two key architects of the early American suburbs—both drew inspiration from the sprawling grassy vistas of wealthy English estates, asserting the moral character of a well-kept lawn over that of productive farmland, and bestowing the aesthetics of the wealthy onto the emergent middle class.
While the early suburbs eschewed most agrarian ideals—we are not peasants!—the visions of democracy carried forth. In direct contrast to the walled estates of England, Downing discouraged Americans from installing high fences or hedges, inviting them to open up their lots to the front to create a shared civic landscape, visually connected across properties. In his 1989 essay, Why Mow?, Michael Pollan illustrates how the American front lawn acts as a “unifying force,” spilling over from house to house, neighborhood to neighborhood, stretching across state and political boundaries like an “unbounded democratic river.”3
The front lawn and its care thus becomes a civic duty: a balancing act between individual ownership and collective conformity. How one stewards their portion of the Great Green River—and the ways they choose to pollute it (with weeds, ornaments, or signage)—becomes a referendum on one’s participation in democracy.
Yard Art as National Subconscious
Enter the flamingo and friends: the bane of homeowners’ associations across the country. Yard art symbolizes a lack of taste—a kind of aesthetic clutter that is easily overlooked. But in her remarkable book, The Flamingo in the Garden: American Yard Art and the Vernacular Landscape, Colleen J. Sheehy dissects the historic and symbolic potency of lawn ornaments—from flamingos and garden gnomes to cement deer and Virgin Marys—as vessels of self-expression amid a never-ending carpet of conformity.
Historically, taste is the protected province of the middle class—the refined, restrained curation of one’s means, performed in direct opposition to both the excesses of the wealthy and the vulgarity of the poor.4 Suburban taste thrives on quietude—something lawn ornaments certainly are not. This makes them countercultural in a way—a celebration of joy and humor amid the policing of restraint.
Like many forms of kitsch, lawn ornaments speak to us in ways we don’t always consciously register. What is expressed, Sheehy argues, is often subliminal—a mix of inherited cultural meanings and subconsciously held ideals. The gazing globe, for instance, operates similarly to the snow globe, providing a miniaturized portrait of an idealized world. Only the world represented here is of one’s own reality: the garden, house, and heavens all captured in perfect harmony.5
Sheehy’s analysis pulls inspiration from the writings of J.B. Jackson, the great theorist of America’s overlooked places. Jackson wrote extensively about America’s vernacular landscapes—strip malls, gas stations, trailer parks, and fairgrounds—theorizing the ways that these ordinary, everyday places speak more to our lives than their picturesque counterparts. In the same way vernacular speech arises through real patterns of communication, beyond the rules of any “official” language, vernacular landscapes arise through the informal patterns of our lives as actually lived. What they might lack in taste, they make up for in truth. Our national subconscious bubbles up from beneath the grass, raw and unrefined.
“Over and over again I have said that common-place aspects of the contemporary landscape, the streets and houses and fields and places of work, could teach us a great deal not only about American history and American society but about ourselves and how we relate to the world.”
- J.B. Jackson, Discovering the Vernacular Landscape
The history of lawn ornamentation extends back to ancient Rome, where statuary infused outdoor gardens with the mythology of the divine. In the 19th century, garden writers like Gertrude Jekyll helped popularize statuary here in America, while advancements in plaster and plastics manufacturing made them more and more accessible to the middle and lower classes.6 The American yard thus became an equally symbolic space to those ancient gardens—even if the entourage is just a bit more tacky.
The garden gnome, for instance, is a direct descendant of the 18th-century ornamental hermits: paid performers hired by aristocrats to live on their estates and perform a life of solitude and contemplation. These hermits evoked the ancient lineage of bards and Christian saints who sought moral clarity within the wilderness, rejecting the chaos and decadence of urban life (and underlining the anxieties of the aristocracy at the time).7
America cultivated its own version of these hermits through the likes of Henry David Thoreau and Johnny Appleseed (who, by the way, also hails from Leominster, Massachusetts). Both men stand in direct contrast to domesticated, suburban life—both rejected the conventional markers of masculinity (property ownership, family, wealth) for more spiritual paths, marked by intimacy with (rather than dominion over) the land. The call of these wild sages haunts the psyche of suburban men in the form of the garden gnome, even if their wisdom has been somewhat diluted by mass production.
But what of our hero, the flamingo? How did this strange, garish bird come to roost upon our nation’s front lawns? Much like turfgrass and the garden gnome, the pink plastic flamingo is a bizarre dilution of the grand estates of yore. King Louis XIV famously kept flamingos on the grounds at Versailles as part of his royal menagerie—an ostentatious display of imperial power, featuring a host of exotic animals captured by the French East India Company. Aviaries remained popular displays of wealth throughout the Victorian and Gilded Ages, symbolizing one’s access to the rare and the exotic. Captured in the glassworks of Louis Tiffany, the flamingo was once synonymous with refinement, conjuring a quiet sense of elegance and gentle grace.
The story of the flamingo’s descent into vulgarity is as American as key lime pie, and it begins—where else?—in everyone’s favorite cultural backwater: Florida.
Tune in next time as we explore the history and development of the Everglades, and how the flamingo’s early extirpation from Florida cemented it as a symbol of exotic leisure and fantasy.
Hype over Cape Cod Flamingo reaches new heights. (n.d.). Mass Audubon. https://www.massaudubon.org/news/latest/cape-cod-flamingo
Menninghaus, W. (2009). On the 'Vital Significance' of Kitsch: Walter Benjamin's Politics of 'Bad Taste'.
Pollan, M. (1989, May 28). Why Mow? New York Times Magazine, 6-22.
Price, J. (1999). Flight maps: Adventures with nature in modern America. Basic Books.
Sheehy, C.J. (1998). The Flamingo in the Garden: American Yard Art and the Vernacular Landscape. Garland Publishing, Inc.
Ibid.
Campbell, G. (2013). The hermit in the garden : from imperial Rome to ornamental gnome. Oxford University Press.
Having lived in Florida and with family members that have plastic flamingos in their yards, I thoroughly enjoyed your article.
Wow Kirk, you’re such a great writer. I can only hope to emulate 1/10th of your wordsmithing someday. If my brain ever works again. But I learned things about the development of our culture that I’d never thought about before. The vulgarity of kitsch having a more elevated origin for instance. And I loved your description of buying your own flamingo. Such rich imagery. I was right there with you. Next winter (in Finland) I’m now probably gonna order a flamingo, thanks to you. And my husband’s gonna rage.